PLS HELP... Which executioner is the more humane, he who kills you in a few minutes or he who drags the life out of you in the course of many years? in the story The Bet

Respuesta :

In Anton Chekhov's "The Bet," the financier battles that the death penalty is better than life detainment. However, a large portion of the visitors at his gathering oppose this idea.  

Among the financier's visitors are writers and learned people; they object to capital punishment, thinking that it's unethical and against Christian purposes. Some say that capital punishment ought to be discarded out. However, the investor deviates, fighting that capital punishment is, in reality, less cruel than life-long imprisonment. The investor inquires as to whether Capital discipline is justified? Further, he asks about which executioner do the guests support more, the one who kills quickly, or the second, who slowly takes out life in several moments?

Among the visitors is a young legal advisor, who is around a quarter century of age. When he contends that "life on any terms" is superior to death, the financier bangs the table with his clenched hand, and hastily wagers the legal counselor two million rubles that he can't remain in isolation for a long time. Similarly careless, the attorney claims that he can remain restricted for not just five, but rather for a span of fifteen long years. The financier takes the bet.  

Incidentally, toward the finish of the fifteen years, the legal advisor has experienced detachment. He has had no bearing to his learning. Because perusing and practicing on the potential of the human personality and soul is incomplete without imparting these plans to others. Without fraternity, he has lost faith in regards to life.

The legal representative chooses to leave before the named time, in turn relinquishing the prize. In any case, he sets out his head and nods off. The interested banker, who has been watching to check whether the bet is over, finds a skeleton of a thin man with wavy hair, shaggy beard, and depressed cheeks. The legal counselor seems like the life has, surely, been hauled out of him, similarly as the broker has anticipated.

To conclude, in my opinion, if each of us looks for a peace-loving culture and life then the requirement of such punishments and executioners won't be necessary to weigh humanity in a society. However, both, the banker and the young lawyer, show us the sight of suffering that the two types of executioners can bring in life. Life, on any term, is not possible and ending a life at once also depletes the chances of a man to change in life. Certainly, this is the message that the writer wants to bring in light for the audience.