Read the excerpts from "Take the Tortillas Out of Your Poetry" and "Speaking Arabic."
My friend had concluded that if he took his language and culture out of his poetry, he stood a better chance of
receiving a fellowship. He took out his native language, the poetic patois of our reality, the rich mixture of
Spanish, English, pachuco and street talk which we know so well. In other words, he took the tortillas out of
his poetry, which is to say he took the soul out of his poetry.
At a neighborhood fair in Texas, somewhere between the German Oom-pah Sausage Stand and the Mexican
Gorditas booth, I overheard a young man say to his friend, "I wish I had a heritage. Sometimes I feel-so
lonely for one." And the tall American trees were dangling their thick branches right down over his head.
Which best states how the structure of each excerpt supports a different tone?
Anaya structures his text as an anecdote, which gives it a humorous tone, while Nye structures her text as a
counterclaim, which gives it a defensive tone.
Anaya structures his text as an explanation, which gives it an authoritative tone, while Nye structures her text as
an impression, which gives it a soothing tone.
Anaya structures his text as a theory, which gives it an academic tone, while Nye structures her text as a list,
which gives it an unemotional tone
Mark this and return
Next
Submit

Respuesta :

In "Take the Tortillas Out of Your Poetry" by Anaya, the structure of the excerpt as an anecdote contributes to a reflective and serious tone rather than a humorous tone. An anecdote is a short narrative that usually conveys a deeper message or insight, and in this case, Anaya uses it to explore the impact of removing one's language and culture from poetry. This structure allows the reader to engage with the personal experience of the narrator and understand the emotional weight behind the act of cultural erasure. On the other hand, in "Speaking Arabic" by Nye, the structure as a reflective observation supports a contemplative and empathetic tone rather than a defensive tone. Nye presents a scene at a neighborhood fair where she overhears a young man expressing a sense of longing for heritage. By structuring the text in this way, Nye invites readers to empathize with the young man's feelings of loneliness and the universal desire for connection to one's roots. Therefore, a more accurate statement regarding the structure of each excerpt and its impact on tone could be: Anaya structures his text as an anecdote, which gives it a reflective and serious tone, while Nye structures her text as a reflective observation, which gives it a contemplative and empathetic tone.